Architectural Ponderings

Buy Me A House – A Developer’s Dream and Its Critique

I  regularly receive in my inbox websites of new residential developments. Below are the floor plans of one of such projects. It stood out to me because of the exterior renders that I quite liked, so I was keen to discover more. I found the floor plans close but not quite. Don’t get me wrong, they are good, however, for me some things missed the mark.

From the disclaimer available on the website, I understand these are just suggestions and not “actual plans” as these can and will be personalized upon buying the property. However, most people haven’t spent years studying and drawing floor plans, so this is what they will use as points of reference for available options. Thus, this is what I’ll be commenting on.

 



Type 1 –  option 1

I understand that the desire is to showcase how many bedrooms can be created, however a few things pop up:
• The master bedroom has three closets with a total width of under two meters. For two people. Really? Unless this is a house for a minimalist family the clothing of the parents will either spill into the kids’ rooms or they will take over a secondary room. You’ve worked hard to own a house and you end up with the least surface of all the members in the household? Yes, taking a bedroom and turning into a dressing is perfectly fine, but what is one to do if there are enough kids to fill all the rooms?…
• Talking about closets. The two secondary bedrooms on the first floor. One has 3 closets while the other has only one. How does that work?
• This is a big residence. Lots of space. Lots of people. Easily five, as I see from the number of bedrooms, and let’s not forget possible guests. So where is the storage room? The itsy bitsy thing on the ground floor next to the staircase is the storage room?… You really mean to tell me that will be enough to house the vacuum cleaner, the iron, the ironing board, the boxes grandma gave you, the childhood toys the husband is unwilling to let go of, the kids clothing found to sentimental to release, the pickles picked up while traveling through Germany, the China set from aunt Sylvia, and so on ?…
• I’ve noticed this trend of using the attic to place sports equipment, and in all honestly I find it confusing. If you’ve packed the other two floors so tightly and you need so much space, how come you have the option to use half a floor (at times the full attic) as a gym? I don’t have anything against the idea of having a gym, I just feel the example used is not representative for the average use of that particular space. Most of the residences of this type I have visited so far, ended up using the attic space as a storage/dressing/extra office space.

What if the master bedroom was in the attic? Plenty of space for a dressing. Toss in an en suite, maybe even the office, or the guest room. Put all the kids all together on the first floor. If not enough of them, turn one of the rooms into a common space where they can have all sorts of activities which, as an added bonus, will allow the living room to be a much more relaxed space. Leave the washing machine on this floor as this is where most laundry will come from, but allow more space for laundry to be stored in.


Type 1 –  option 2

• I like this version better in regard to the bedrooms. I still don’t like however, having to access the living room through the kitchen. And I do think the kitchen could benefit from a completely different layout.
• Also, one of the things I don’t really understand is the separation of the living room area through the placement of the couch with the back at the rest of the floor. Though there are exceptions, most people like communicating spaces and being able to talk to people without having to turn around all the time. So why have an open floor plan if people will have to strain their necks?
They will look out the window? Most definitely when alone, but not when entertaining. The parent will want to be able to keep an eye on the kids, the host will want to know who needs a refill on their drink, the kids will keep an eye on each other in order to pull a new prank, and so on…
• Lastly, if you do have a piano, show it off! Make it a feature! Don’t just glue it on a wall as in “Well, that’s where it fitted!”. And turn the couch around so that people can actually see the person playing. A little bit of recognition is good for one’s self esteem! 



Type 2 –  option 1

• The aforementioned issues of the bedrooms, storage and kitchen still stand. I mention here, once again, the layout of the kitchen. The three main elements of the space, the sink, stove and fridge work closely together. We tend to get things out of the fridge, pass them through the sink and dunk them in a pot on the stove. The ideal layout would be a triangle with large enough sides to allow one to move freely, yet not so large as to have to walk too far while carrying delicate items. With that being said, the location of the fridge is definitely off.


Type 2 –  option 2

• Same as above, with one more mention. There is a large beautiful table for six right by the kitchen. Yet, right next to it there is a cramped bar element with two chairs that can easily block the circulation in the space. If the room was big enough, the two elements would not collide, but this space is not large enough. You want both the bar and the table? Sure! Change the layout of the kitchen and it can all work much better. This version cramps the dining area while wasting space in the kitchen.


Type 3 –  option 1

• The ground floor space is beautifully open and communicative. However, the layout of the kitchen, while nice for watching outside, will force its users to keep their back at the rest of the floor. I would thus suggest leaving the line at the wall with the window simple, removing the short side of the L, and adding an island. The island will add counter space, provide communication with the rest and the option of a bar.


Type 3 –  option 2

• A little bit of nitpicking here, I like the combo kitchen-dining table. I would however make them out of the same material so that they feel like one element instead of just two pieces placed one next to the other.


Type 4 –  option 1

• I like the entrance through the middle of the floor. It allows for a much more relaxed and elegant entrance. I do however dislike the placement of the dining table. No matter what you do, four people will, at any point in time, look over their shoulders. They will either try to look out the window or towards the living room where the rest of the party will be having their fun. All this can be easily sorted by rotating the table with 90 degrees.
• I also don’t appreciate the layout of the kitchen. True, it is large and generous, but the stove is so far from the fridge that you need to be quite fast on your feet and most likely end up with a muscle ache and a pinch of  frustration.
• Probably just a mistake, but none the less, even editors have proof readers. The corner closet located in the lower left bedroom of the first floor is a mystery to me. How is one supposed to reach it?
• We have all this amazing space on the top floor, where we created a secondary living space. Yet, the washing machine and dryer are out in the open. Seriously? Couldn’t they have a space of their own, where the sight of a laundry basked would not make a host cringe? There is plenty of space!
• I love how all the bedrooms on the first floor pale in comparison to the one in the attic. Not even the master bedroom can come close. Really? Who sleeps there? Also, where do they store their clothes?


Type 4 –  option 2

Now, let’s see! This layout gives me the feeling it was done late and somewhat in a hurry, just to make sure there is a second option.
• The TV in the living room is not aligned with couch area so watching it is bound to make a physio-therapist have plenty of work. The piano can’t really be admired. And the armchair sitting right in the middle of the circulation makes one slalom through the space.
• The kitchen issues are the same as before and none of the secondary bedrooms has any proper storage in place. Huh! Extreme minimalism anybody…

 

Project: Nieuwe Woning Haarzicht Vleuten
All images courtesy of the website of the project as seen on 07/2018. 


Click here for my “-Re” House projects
Click here for my “-Re” Adapt projects


 

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.